What Not to Write About in a College Essay

What Colleges Look for in Essays

• Admissions committees use essays to understand who you are beyond your grades and test scores.
• The essay should highlight your values, perspective, and voice in a unique, memorable way.
• A great essay demonstrates qualities like resilience, critical thinking, and personal growth while helping you stand out.

Cliché College Essay Topics to Avoid‍♀️

1. Resume/Academic Achievements

• Why Avoid:
• Comes across as repetitive (this info is already in your application).
• Focuses on achievements rather than your personality or growth.
• What to Do Instead:
• Pick one meaningful experience and dive deep into how it shaped you.

2. The Mission Trip Essay

• Why Avoid:
• Overdone and can unintentionally sound self-congratulatory or tone-deaf.
• Often portrays communities in need in a generic or problematic way.
• What to Do Instead:
• Focus on unexpected values, like learning boundaries, empathy, or cultural exchange.

3. Sports Challenge Essays

• Why Avoid:
• Generic and predictable: winning, losing, teamwork, resilience, etc.
• Often spends too much time describing the event rather than personal growth.
• What to Do Instead:
• Explore how sports taught you unique lessons (e.g., how being a cornerback helped you analyze literature better).

4. The Big Performance

• Why Avoid:
• Similar to sports essays—often follows a predictable formula.
• Focuses too much on the performance itself rather than self-reflection.
• What to Do Instead:
• Highlight a specific, unusual moment or what you learned about yourself post-performance.

5. The Cliché Immigration Story

• Why Avoid:
• Common themes like cultural adjustment and identity can feel generic.
• What to Do Instead:
• Focus on a unique aspect of your experience, such as navigating a specific challenge or a single defining moment.

6. Why X Person Is Your Hero

• Why Avoid:
• Often shifts focus away from you and onto someone else.
• Admissions committees want to learn about you, not your hero.
• What to Do Instead:
• Explore how your hero inspired specific actions or personal growth in your life.

7. The Tough Grade You Got

• Why Avoid:
• May not feel like a significant challenge compared to other essays in the pile.
• Draws attention to academic struggles instead of strengths.
• What to Do Instead:
• Focus on challenges that reveal resilience and creativity in overcoming obstacles.

8. Your First Heartbreak

• Why Avoid:
• Hard to make it unique or significant.
• Risks coming across as overly dramatic or immature.
• What to Do Instead:
• Choose a topic that better highlights your growth and values.

9. Illegal or Unethical Activities

• Why Avoid:
• Mentions of illegal or unethical behavior can raise red flags for admissions.
• What to Do Instead:
• Focus on moments that build trust and confidence in your ability to contribute positively to campus life.

If You’re Determined to Use a Cliché Topic

Here’s how to make it work:
1. Choose an Unexpected Angle:
- For example, if writing about sports, focus on how it helped you develop unrelated skills (e.g., public speaking or analyzing literature).

• Highlight Unique Values:

• Avoid generic values like perseverance; aim for unexpected ones like creativity, humility, or balance.

• Focus on Reflection Over Description:

• Spend less time recounting events and more time exploring their personal impact.

• Zoom In:

• Narrow down your topic to a single defining moment or experience that’s meaningful to you.

Start Writing Your Essay Today ✍️

Crafting a standout college essay takes effort and reflection, but avoiding clichés can make your story shine. Focus on personal growth, unexpected insights, and authentic storytelling.

Next: Read 1200+ student guides covering all aspects of student life.

❤ If you liked all this, consider supporting us by checking out Tiny Skills - 250+ Top Work & Personal Skills Made Easy