Critical Reading For Exams / Long Reading Comprehension 3


Passage 1 
The following is an excerpt by Lord Chesterfield in a letter to his son written in 1747. 

Women have, in general, but one object, which is their beauty; upon which scarce any flattery is too gross for  them to follow. Nature has hardly formed a woman ugly enough to be insensible to flattery upon her person; if her  face is so shocking that she must, in some degree, be conscious of it, her figure and air, she trusts, make ample  amends for it. If her figure is deformed, her face, she thinks, counterbalances it. If they are both bad, she comforts  herself that she has graces, a certain manner, a je ne sais quoi still more engaging than beauty. This truth is evident  from the studied and elaborate dress of the ugliest woman in the world. An undoubted, uncontested, conscious  beauty is, of all women, the least sensible of flattery upon that head; she knows it is her due, and is therefore  obliged to nobody for giving it her. She must be flattered upon her understanding; which, though she may possibly  not doubt of herself, yet she suspects that men may distrust.  D. not mistake me, and think that I mean to recommend to you abject and criminal flattery: no; flatter nobody’s  vices or crimes: on the contrary, abhor and discourage them. But there is no living in the world without a com-  plaisant indulgence for people’s weaknesses, and innocent, though ridiculous vanities. If a man has a mind to be  thought wiser, and woman handsomer, than they really are, their error is a comfortable one to themselves, and an  innocent one with regard to other people; and I would rather make them my friends by indulging them in it, than  my enemies by endeavoring (and that to no purpose) to undeceive them. 

Passage 2 
The following is an excerpt by Samuel Clemens in a lecture given in 1882 on advice to youth. 

Now as to the matter of lying. You want to be very careful about lying; otherwise you are nearly sure to get  caught. Once caught, you can never again be, in the eyes of the good and the pure, what you were before. Many a  young person has injured himself permanently through a single clumsy and ill-finnished lie, the result of careless-  ness born of incomplete training. Some authorities hold that the young ought not to lie at all. That, of course, is  putting it rather stronger than necessary; still, while I cannot go quite so far as that, I do maintain, and I believe I  am right, that the young ought to be temperate in the use of this great art until practice and experience shall give  them that confidence, elegance, and precision which alone can make attention to detail – these are the require-  ments; these, in time, will make the student perfect; upon these, and upon these only, may he rely as the sure foun-  dation for future eminence. 
 



On the sheer face of what is written, which position in Passage (1) would Clemens support?

Any flattery contains an element of untruth.
A truly pretty woman will have to be flattered for her intelligence.
Women all appreciate being flattered.
Abject and criminal flattery is objectionable.
Flattery lying is something to be condoned.

By suggesting that perfection in lying is the only path to eminence, as the author does in Passage (2), what can we infer about leadership in government?

Lying leaders is an appropriate and just extension given that they represent the people.
All government leaders are liars of superior accomplishment.
After a position of eminence is achieved, the benefit of lying ceases.
Leadership has the responsibility to teach others the ills of lying since they are the experts.
They may be trusted to speak the truth now that they have taken an oath of office.

Regarding both Passage (1) and Passage (2), what is the relational ironic element considering each of these very differently presented passages independently? A. B. C. D. E.

Passage (1) supports lying and Passage (2) dissuades lying.
Both Passage (1) and Passage (2) leave the moral position of lying up to the discretion of the reader.
Both Passage (1) and Passage (2) support lying.
Passage (1) dissuades lying and Passage (1) supports lying.
Both Passage (1) and Passage (2) dissuade lying.

What does the author in Passage (1) caution his son relative to this practice of flattery?

Only use flattery when you are sincere and totally objective.
Flattery should not be given meritoriously but for the gaining of some advantage on the recipient.
It is alright to use flattery when it is an obvious lie if the situation warrants.
Flattery should not be given to the extent it qualifies as criminal or a lie.
Flattery is a tool that, when used properly, may be perfected such as to convince the recipient of even greater, more abject flattery.

What writing style is employed by the author in Passage (2)?

Sardonic
Lofty
Extended metaphor
Metaphysical
Satire

In what way are Passage (1) and Passage (2) most parallel?

Although using different styles, both endorse the adage that the ends justify the means.
Although in differing ways, both are giving advice to youth.
Arguably, both passages condone any conduct necessary to gain prominence.
Both passages agree that the intellect of the recipient of a lie is less than the teller of the lie.
Both passages agree that prominence and eminence are the ultimate goals of lying.

What information suggests that the statement in Passage (1), line (1), “Women have, in general, but one object, which is their beauty” might make the author to consider this to be an appropriate position?

Because the letter was written by a father to a son in order to help the son find a suitable mate
Because the letter says that ugly women have to rely upon dress
Because the letter was written during a period when women didn’t have rights
Because the letter says that sensible flattery is appreciated by all women unless they know they are pretty
Because the letter indicates that flattery about a woman’s beauty is universally acceptable

What is the general tone of the letter in Passage (1)?

Laudable
Humorous
Foreboding
Sincere
Deleterious

What is inferred in the sentences, “An undoubted, uncontested, conscious beauty is, of all women, the least sensible of flattery upon that head; she knows it is her due, and is therefore obliged to nobody for giving it her. She must be flattered

Flatter a woman’s intelligence if she is actually pretty.
Even a pretty woman has doubts, so flattery is still warranted.
Establish trust by reassurance when a woman is actually pretty.
Truly pretty women are not as intelligent as others, so it may take more compliments to gain their favor.
Because a truly pretty woman will distrust your sincerity, restate you flattery so she can understand.

What advice does the author give to our youth about lying in Passage (2)?

Lying to authorities is less acceptable than to acquaintances.
There are various gradations of lies, and the harshest should be reserved when possible.
Lying is evil and should be avoided whenever possible.
Lying should be used in moderation until perfected and for personal gains.
Once perfected, the art of lying may be used only occasionally so as not to get caught.