Critical Reading For Exams / Short Reading Comprehension 20


Someone may say: there have been plenty of princes, very successful in warfare, who have had a reputation for  generosity. But I answer: either the prince is spending his own money and that of his subjects, or he is spending  someone else’s. In the first case, he ought to be sparing; in the second case, he ought to spend money like water. 

Any prince at the head of his army, which lives on loot, extortion, and plunder, dispose of other people’s property,  and is bound to be very generous; otherwise, his soldiers would desert him. You can always be a more generous  giver when what you give is not yours or your subjects’; Cyrus, Caesar, and Alexander were generous in this way. 

Spending what belongs to other people does no harm to your reputation, rather it enhances it; only spending your  own substance harms you. And there is nothing that wears out faster than generosity; even as you practice it, you  lose the means of practicing it, and you become either poor and contemptible or (in the course of escaping poverty)  rapacious and hateful.  (5)  (10)
 



According to the passage, what information makes the first sentence, “Someone may say: there have been plenty of princes, very successful in warfare, who have had a reputation for generosity” self-evident?

The author explains that generosity is easily achieved if you have sufficient means with which to be generous but if that reliance is upon what you or your subjects have instead of pillage, generosity will be short lived.
The author takes the position that the important issue is to be considered as generous even if that is not the case.
The author presents the position that in order for one to be generous, he must be a great warrior.
The author informs that those giving away other’s possessions are bound to be generous and since the prince presented in the first sentence is very successful, he must have plenty of other’s possessions.
The author tells us that one of the ways for a prince to be generous is to give away what personal wealth and that of his subjects.

According to the article, what might cause desertion among soldiers?

Harsh living conditions without adequate food
Long stays in harsh elements and weather
Long periods of time without permanent shelter
Long periods of time away from family and home
Insufficient portion of bounty